Gary Ireland asked Australian football expert friend Ron Smith a few questions on the relevance and importance of juggling. Ron is a former Australian National Mens National Team Analyst and former Head Coach of the Australian Institute of Sport (AIS). Ron worked as assistant to Gus Hiddink at the 2006 World Cup in Germany and provided invaluable support for Hiddink in the run up to the successful campaign. (note, this interview took place when RS was working with Australian National team).
Gary: Do you encourage the players on the Australian Youth and Senior team to juggle?
Ron: I'm not in a position to influence what the players in the national team do, but when I watch them warming up in their own time I see plenty of them juggling the ball or playing games in small groups that involve juggling or 1 touch play to keep the ball in the air.
Gary: How often should players be juggling?
Ron: I think juggling becomes a part of everyday training and it's a personal thing. juggling is a way of keeping in touch with the ball and all players like to develop feeling. It's a bit like putting for golfers, you have to feel the putt just like you have to feel the ball when you are playing with it.
Gary: Is there a direct correlation between the best jugglers and the best players?
Ron: I don't have any evidence but if you watch the best players in the world they can all juggle the ball and perform amazing tricks. I coached Josip Simumic for three years at the AIS (he's the captain of Croatia) and at 15 years of age he juggled the ball non stop for 3 hours, I have a video of him doing it. Joe has played 98 A Internationals for Croatia and will be at the 2012 Euro's.
Gary: Who is the best juggler you've coached seen in your opinion?
Ron: Joe Simunic would take some beating but Ronaldinho is also amazing.
Gary: Many people, including coaches, often comment that juggling isn't relevant to the game or that it's for 'show offs'. I've heard comments such as 'you should be in a circus'. How do you explain to these people that the Zidane's, Ronaldinho's and Henry's have terrific juggling skills and that the best players in the world tend to have fantastic tricks.
Ron: People who make those comments don't see the difference between developing 'touch" and how that is applied in the game. Players don't juggle the ball during the game but that's not a reason for not doing it.
Gary: What are the benefits of juggling? How does juggling help a player? What specific attributes does juggling develop? (coordination? affinity? balance? dexterity, touch, feel etc)
Ron: Juggling definitely develops touch and feeling. All the top players who have great technique and touch can juggle the ball. balance and coordination are developed through juggling as well as both sides of the body.
Gary: What different types of juggling do you encourage. i.e in pairs or on the run
Ron: I think any form of juggling is good because it maintains feeling once it has been developed. i come back to golfers and putting. the top performers have a high level of touch and feeling and that has to be maintained. Top pianists notice a difference in performance if they don't practice for one week, so why should footballers or golfers be any different.
Gary: 'Soccer-Tennis' is a popular form of juggling. Is this something you endorse/recommend? Do your players on the National team play soccer-tennis?
Ron: Football tennis is not only fun to play but you can play around with the rules to force one or two touches etc. At the 2006 World Cup the players played football tennis regularly and so did the staff. We had a court set out permanently behind Guus Hiddink's residence and we played there most days after lunch.
John Owens was the assistant Academy Director at Liverpool Football Club for 18 years, coaching 9 -18 year olds. He coached Michael Owen, Steven Gerrard, Jamie Carragher, Steven Warnock, Darren Potter and others at Liverpool F.C and the likes of Joe Cole, Wes Brown on the England youth team. John hired SBC Founder Gary Ireland to work with Liverpool F.C youth players at ‘The Academy’ in 2003-2004. Gary is also a former personal assistant of Wiel Coerver working with Wiel in the Middle East and in the USA. Gary interviewed his mentor John Owens below on the subject of juggling. See below.
I don’t think that players juggle enough in general. Juggling helped my balance, coordination, touch, timing and more importantly, timing. I played my best soccer when my juggling was at my best. Do you encourage the players at Liverpool FC to juggle?
Yes we do encourage our players to juggle. It is part of their individual work with the ball. It is not just about juggling but we encompass the whole area of ball familiarization, using different parts of the foot, thigh, chest and head. They can progress from individual work to pairs and in larger groups. We also use the wall in our indoor arena to vary the challenge. Players who show a high ability of individual skill with the ball are usually the ones who show the best control and the best at weighting their passes.
I have spent many years playing foot tennis/soccer tennis, which helped me tremendously in my development. I also know it helped all of our coaching staff so I absolutely agree with you. It’s one of the best way to improve touch and timing. How often should players be juggling?
There should be time in each session to work individually with the ball (juggling is just a part of that). It can be fitted in well as part of the warm-up linked with the physical element of the pre=session routine. Individual ball work is also a useful part of a session to place between two high intensity sections. Twice a week with the full-time players we have specific sessions for the development of individual skills. Over the year we will cover the full range of skills with the ball (control, passing, volleying, heading, etc.) Many sessions include 2 v 2 skills games and larger games of football tennis and head tennis. (in head-tennis the net is higher and the ball must be sent over the net with a header) In some games players must take two touches each. This gives them practice with a stress on the quality of their first touch, like in the real game. Those who are good jugglers usually do well in these types of skills games.
Who is the best juggler at LFC (youth) in your opinion?
In our team that won the F.A Youth Cup (U/18 men) last season, we had a player, Adam Hammill, who has exceptional individual skills with the ball. Of course, some of his moves are not directly applicable to the game situation, but some do unsettle the defenders and can give him the edge in dribbling situations. When I was manager of England U/15s, Joe Cole (now with Chelsea) was just as adept at juggling and ball manipulation skills. The real challenge for these highly skilled players is to use their ability in an effective way that benefits the team, rather than it simply be a show of their skills.
Many people, including coaches, often comment that juggling isn’t relevant to the game or that it’s for 'show offs'. I have 40+ ways of getting the ball off the ground and numerous tricks and flicks, which, when rehearsed regularly without doubt help me perform better because it helps my balance, touch, and co-ordination. I’ve heard comments such as 'you should be in a circus' when showing these tricks. I happen to work on ‘method juggling’ and juggling in motion for a greater and more realistic challenge rather than ‘hackeysack’ tricks. Hubert Vogelsinger’s instep training which was widely used here in colleges by people such as former Stanford coach Bobby Clark who I met while coaching together at Vogelsinger’s camp before he worked at Stanford, is a form of training which incorporates juggling to some very advanced technical training which I call ‘aerial control’. How do you explain to these people that the Maradona’s, Zidanes, Ronaldinho's and Henry's have terrific juggling skills and that the best players in the world tend to have fantastic tricks.
My earlier answers cover this question. Overall, those who do not see the relevance of ball manipulation activities like juggling do not realize the concept of transference of skills. A very important point here is for the coach to accept the responsibility of helping the player to transfer these skills to the real game situations. If no transfer is made then the juggling skills will remain in isolation and will not benefit the player in his overall game. I think this is the point that the critics of juggling are making when they claim that it is just a circus act.
A famous phrase often said to anyone juggling is "why do you bother doing that when you cannot do it on the pitch". Many coaches or lower level players who were never able to juggle or people who have never or rarely played the game seem to say this. How would you answer that one.
Juggling is not practiced to be a move that is copied exactly in the actual game. When you watch ballerinas warming up, they perform different moves to help them to execute the actual moves on stage. Nobody expects a footballer to juggle in a real game but the players who are good jugglers do show the best control ( first touch ) in the game – whether that be a touch to control the ball for themselves or to lay a ball with one-touch perfectly into the path of a colleague. All footballers should seek to master the football, like the precision shown by golfers, snooker players, etc
In all the places you have coached football have you ever been anywhere were juggling is given the same importance as in South America.
I have not coached in South America, but by all accounts they take their individual skills very seriously. In the past in Europe we focused so much on game play, rather than individual development. The guiding principle for our Academy system is to practice three times for every one game session, so that the time for work on individual skills is available. Although we aim to emulate the individual ability of the South American players, we have to seek to do it in the framework of our own culture. This culture will be shaped by the style of play in games and the physical and psychological makeup of the players of that country. With the movement of players from all over the world to our Premier League, our young players are influenced by many foreign players which lessens the idea of a typical stereotype.
What are the benefits of juggling?
The main benefit of juggling is to encourage a good touch and mastery of the ball. It will also improve a player’s physical co-ordination and suppleness. As a player improves their repertoire of skills, they will be able to be less predictable and more creative in their play. Young children thrive on competition and contests of these skills can enthuse young players to want to learn and improve.
The coach should not leave the players to practice juggling in isolation. To get the transference to specific football skills, like touch, control, feel for the ball, etc. the coach should help to make this link with practices for control to follow sessions on juggling. So juggling for the sake of juggling is what annoys some coaches. In lots of skills practices we overdo the skills to emphasize the practice of it. For instance with shielding – we can get 1 v 1 for a minute in a small area to test the players ability to use his body to protect the ball. In the real game we do not want a player shielding it for a minute or more. The player must choose firstly whether he needs to shield it. Then he should shield it for as short a time as possible to get out of a tight position and safely pass, shoot or continue a dribble. So our practices are not always perfect replicas of the game situation. We do not practice shielding for the sake of shielding the ball as an end. Shielding the ball is a means to an end – getting free with the ball away from a defender. It then depends on the ability of the coach to lead the player from the practice situation through to the real game, i.e. through the transfer of skills. Also, with regard to the fact that we do not see juggling in the actual game, we also do not see players getting into the type of stretch positions (e.g. hamstring, groin,..) during play but we still feel OK about our players doing these stretches in preparation. They are not doing them to replicate exactly in the game.
John, thanks for your time and thanks for you sharing your knowledge with me. I agree with your thoughts which are of course hard to disagree with considering players such as Steven Gerrard are products of your guidance! You may have just silenced the juggling cynics. Good luck this season at Liverpool FC.
Copyright. Gary Ireland. Soccerbook Consulting. The contents of this document are not to be sold, copied or re-produced without the acknowledgement of the authors. Under the copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) the photocopy or reproduction is not to be "used for any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research.”. No part of this document may be reproduced, in whole or in part, without the specific written permission of Gary Ireland unless otherwise stated, all material on this web site is © copyright Gary Ireland. To obtain permission to reprint text or images, please contact email@example.com or firstname.lastname@example.org